The Recommendation Suites, Vol.1/#2 - Olivia Rodrigo "you seem pretty sad for a girl so in love"
The Recommendation Suites Vol. 1/#2
This series is culled from recommendations given to me by friends, family, acquaintances, coworkers, fellow music dorks and casual fans alike. The only really prerequisite I give when fielding these recommendations is that it must be from this calendar year. All genres are welcome in the Recommendation Suites.
The album: Olivia Rodrigo - you seem pretty sad for a girl so in love
The recommender: Bonnie. Unofficial wedding chauffeur, Pokémon Master and key member of the Front Row Crew.
Long before I ever wrote a single word about a song or an album or interviewed a musician, one of my first music takes was that boys should be able to enjoy listening to women sing love songs with the same enthusiasm that girls enjoyed listening to men sing love songs. Mind you, this was the Attitude Era and such statements of softness were not welcomed by my very male friendgroup. I got torched. (It’s the same sentiment that led me to being a secret Dawson’s Creek superfan.) All that is to say, I would have fucking loved you seem pretty sad for a girl so in love in my teenage days, but I would have loved it in secret. Luckily, now I am a man in my 40s with the confidence to like the things I like out loud. And while I probably don’t love this record in the same I way I would have a quarter-century ago, I really do like it a lot. This is a big, bright, shiny pop record with immaculate production, incredibly catchy hooks, some pretty great grooves and instrumentation, all carried by Olivia Rodrigo’s obvious superstar talents and cuttingly sharp pen.
“drop dead” is a great opener with a huge sound that sets the tone for everything that comes after. “stupid song” is an achingly sweet and lovely love song that turns from piano ballad into a big bouncy pop song with a ton of drive. But for me, you seem pretty sad for a girl so in love really hits another level once we hit “maggots for brains.” I cannot get over how fucking good this song is. Rodrigo sings about being “a sad shell of a woman,” and I think the feeling of being a mess when your lover is away is a universal feeling for anyone who has been deeply in love. I keep coming back to this song as the key to tapping the deep well of emotion on this record. I didn’t hear Rodrigo’s last album and only have a passing familiarity with her debut, mostly because I didn’t think there would be an emotional connection point for me, but this record has proven me wrong. Love, and the ways we process/deal with it, really is the most human of experiences and the basic shapes and colours of it all don’t really change if you’re 18, 25, 41 or 64.
“you + me = <3” is absolutely unreal. I don’t know how you can listen to this and not be singing along to this chorus after the first go-round. And the lyric “They say modern love’s a cruel endeavour\And to that I say ‘fuck it, whatever’”?? FUGGEDABOUDIT! And then to follow up that track with another singalong banger? Brilliant. “my way,” is a brutal takedown of another young lady with the indecency to try to get the attention of Rodrigo’s beau and it’s so much more fun than something so savage should be. “purple” softens the proceedings a bit and finds Rodrigo reflecting on the possible toxicity of all-encompassing love as we shift into the you seem pretty sad portion of the album. (“purple” is the last song on Side A of the vinyl release.)
The back half we venture into of the record is softer in sound, but Rodrigo takes that softness of sound and drills down into feelings with some affectingly reflective and introspective lyrics. “the cure” bathes in the self-doubt and the tricks our minds can play on us when left to our own devices. If I was so inattentive to my wife that she wrote anything as longing and lonely as “begged,” I’d have to pack it in and call it day. At the same time, “begging” also sends me spiraling back to past relationships where I felt like I was rotting on a vine. This shit is so visceral. A+ songwriting here. I’d be remiss if I didn’t mention “what’s wrong with me,” the highlight duet with classic Feelings Guy™, the Cure’s Robert Smith. Rodrigo and Smith are kind of a perfect pairing and there’s no way this hasn’t got a whole new generation of music fans into The Cure. Inspired pairing, no notes. “less,” is a beautifully mournful meditation on being a burden in love and has genuinely made me shed tears on more than one listen. The high point, energy-wise at least, on the back half of the record is undoubtedly the self-empowerment “expectations.” I can’t imagine this anthem hasn’t helped more than a few people get out of romantic relationships doing less than serving them. It’s got cool synths, a huge bass line and that cool sing-song Rodrigo is so good at. “expectations” rocks.
Much like the first record in this series, I don’t think I ever would have given you seem pretty sad for a girl so in love dedicated time if left to my own devices. Hell, it might have never crossed my headphones. But I’m glad I did because it’s an engaging record full of deep insights and big feelings, wrapped up in a shiny package that’s more than difficult to ignore.
Vol. 1/#1 - Station Model Violence “Station Model Violence”
